Why former Speaker McCarthy is Wrong about “Poor President Trump” and Speaker Johnson
Since former McCarthy has chosen to repeat his comments that “I mean, poor President Trump is being the president [and] the speaker at the same time,” it demonstrates a considerable lack of self-awareness and understanding of recent American history, and thus, it cannot go unanswered.
First, let’s start with self-awareness: former Speaker McCarthy is the only Speaker in United States history who did not have the votes to survive a motion to vacate the Speakership. McCarthy throwing shade at Speaker Johnson’s Speakership for lacking the votes in the House Budget Committee is quite ironic, considering McCarthy could not muster the votes to save his job—a job that Speaker Johnson now holds and has performed exceptionally under thinner vote margins than McCarthy’s 10-vote margin.
What shows Speaker McCarthy’s lack of understanding of American history is the implication that President Trump should not have to work to move votes in the U.S. House and that only Trump’s saving the Speaker will make Trump’s “big, beautiful bill” pass, as if the United States has an imperial Presidency where President Trump neither has to lobby, cajole, twist arms, make threats, nor hand out favors for votes.
I wonder if former Speaker McCarthy is living in a parallel universe or a different timeline where Presidents don’t collaborate with the Speaker to advance historic and significant legislation.
Every president who has passed serious legislation or achieved any historic accomplishment during their presidency has done so while working hand-in-glove with the Speaker of the House.
In fact, one sure way for any President to ensure that his main policy initiative fails is to avoid or fail to create a close partnership with the Speaker of the House.
Every president needs the Speaker working tirelessly to advance their priorities, especially in our world with a narrow margin of victory.
Historic, epic, and far-reaching legislation, like the President’s “one big beautiful bill,” requires the Speaker’s continuous support and the President’s active involvement.
To wit, here is a recent list of the most significant legislation passed into law by the President and Speaker working together:
- The New Deal: President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Speaker Sam Rayburn enacted the transformative, nation-altering New Deal.
- The Civil Rights Act of 1964: President Lyndon Johnson and Speaker John McCormack passed the Civil Rights Act. Speaker McCormack’s role was essential for President Johnson’s initiative to pass it.
- Winning the Cold War: President Reagan’s massive military buildup to confront the then Soviet Union could not have succeeded without the active support of Democratic Speaker Tip O’Neill. Their cooperation extended beyond legislative initiatives — Speaker O’Neill assured Soviet Leader Gorbachev that President Reagan spoke for all U.S. citizens, not just the Republican Party.
- The Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001: President George W. Bush and Speaker Hastert worked tirelessly to pass the largest tax cuts in United States history at that time.
- Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit (Part D) and Health Savings Accounts: President George W. Bush’s signature initiative would have failed to pass the House without Speaker Hastert’s tireless efforts on the legislation over nearly a year.
- The Affordable Care Act: Without Speaker Pelosi’s work for over a year and a half on this presidential initiative, there is no doubt that the bill would have failed in the U.S. House.
- Trump’s first Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (TCJA) was a significant legislative achievement for both President Donald Trump and Speaker of the House Paul Ryan, who played a crucial role in its success.
- President Biden’s Infrastructure Bill: No one doubts Speaker Pelosi’s key role in passing President Biden’s signature initiative.
The boots-on-the-ground reality is that if any President wants their signature initiative—whatever it is—to become law, the President must rely on the Speaker of the House to do the day-in, day-out work to pass the legislation. And yes, when necessary, in every single case listed above, the President personally must get involved to lobby, cajole, twist arms, make threats, or hand out favors for votes.
So why is former Speaker McCarthy saying “poor President Trump” when discussing vote wrangling, which has occurred with every President who has successfully passed their signature initiatives into law?
